APPRAISAL BUZZ SPRING 2020 | 19
those used for overtime, unemployment insurance,
workers compensation, or liability. The details of
these tests also vary by state. As a result, there is no
single standard for determining whether an appraiser
is properly treated as an independent contractor.
runs through most tests. The key is generally the
The IRS has summarized its own test in its wage
withholding regulations and states that a worker is
considered an employee when:
The person for whom services are performed
the individual who performs the services
accomplished by the work, but also as to the details
and means by which that result is accomplished. That
employer, not only as to what shall be done, but how it
shall be done.
The following are some key factors relating to control
that need to be considered. When answers to these
questions are “yes,” it is more likely that the appraiser
is really an employee:
perform his or her work?
• Is the appraiser required to be present on the
• Is the appraiser required to work certain hours
or days?
•
•
computer, appraisal software, MLS, laser
measuring device, etc.?
• Is the appraiser paid by the hour or week (as
• Is the appraiser permitted to accept and be paid
appraiser actually take on independent work?
•
•
• Do either of the parties believe an employment
relationship exists?
If the answer to any of these questions is a strong
“yes,” or if the answer to more than a few of these
twice before treating its appraisers as contractors.
CREATING A MORE DEFENSIBLE
INDEPENDENT-CONTRACTOR
RELATIONSHIP
structure their independent contractor arrangements
to minimize potential problems. And frankly, even
actual enforcement has proven low overall.
contractors should use a written independent
contractor agreement spelling out the relationship.
Such an agreement is almost never a controlling
factor in a test, but it can provide clarity regarding the
key points the agreement should cover:
• The independent contractor appraiser has the
right and freedom to work the hours that he or
she deems necessary to perform accepted
appraisals is under the exclusive control of the
appraiser.